Destinations suffering from overtourism are grounding ships carrying toxic gas and millions of passengers.
advertisement
More than 20 million passengers take cruises each year.
Before the pandemic, that number was even higher: about 30 million.
Many European ports where these ships dock are reevaluating their presence as passenger numbers look set to once again exceed pre-pandemic numbers. Some are considering banning them altogether, citing environmental, social and economic concerns.
The 218 cruise ships that sailed through Europe in 2022 emitted more than four times more sulfur oxides than all the continent’s cars, according to the Ministry of Transport and Environment. Last June, the NGO found that these toxic air pollutants from ships are now higher than before COVID-19.
And while the benefits to local economies are debatable, the millions of passengers they bring to European cities each year are causing problems for the people who live there.
Venice wants to prevent cruise ships from entering and exiting the city
Venice has banned large cruise ships from docking in its historic center in 2021.
Due to the lagoon damage, UNESCO threatened to put the city on the endangered list unless it was permanently banned.
They argue that the large ships are causing pollution and eroding the foundations of a city that is already subject to regular flooding. The ban will prevent large cruise ships and container ships from entering Venice’s Giudecca Canal.
There have been previous attempts to stop large ships by overturning previous laws. But pressure increased further in 2019 when a cruise liner crashed into Venice’s port, injuring five people.
And as of the 2021 ban, even cruise lines were on board. After the announcement, the Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA) said it had “supported the new approach for many years” and called it a “major step forward.”
However, the reality of banning large ships from Venice has turned out to be more complex than originally thought. With no new base available for cruise ships outside the city’s lagoon, many ships are still anchored there years after the ban was imposed.
Which European cities have banned cruise ships?
But pollution and overtourism are not just Venice’s problems.
The city of Palma de Mallorca in the Balearic Islands plans to reintroduce restrictions on cruise ships that were first imposed in 2022.
As a result, only three ships will be allowed to enter the port each day, and only one will carry more than 5,000 passengers.
Spanish politicians are also proposing stricter rules on cruise ships’ taxation and use of polluting fuel.
Barcelona closed its northern terminal to cruise passengers on October 22 last year as it grappled with its own problems. Around 340 ships a year will now have to instead berth at the Mor Dadosa jetty, which is the farthest from the city’s residential areas.
With the closure of another terminal at Mare Magnum and the introduction of the one-ship-per-terminal rule, only seven cruise ships can dock in Barcelona at a time.
These measures are based on an agreement with local authorities to relocate cruise ships outside Barcelona city center to reduce the impact of overtourism.
advertisement
By 2026, the South Terminal will also close and all cruises will operate from Adsat Pier.
The Mediterranean is the second-largest cruise market outside the Caribbean, and increasing numbers of passengers are putting an increasing strain on local residents.
In 2022, 50,000 people signed a petition against cruise ships in Marseille, France’s largest cruise port, according to the campaign group Stop Croisières.
Santorini and Dubrovnik also tightened restrictions on cruise lines.
Where else is Cruise causing problems?
The crackdown is also underway at popular ports outside the Mediterranean.
advertisement
Cruise ships visiting Scotland will be subject to new taxes under plans recently announced by the country’s Green Party. It said the levy would tackle the “double challenge” of emissions and overtourism.
Scottish Green co-leader Lorna Slater also argued that one ship emits the same amount of emissions as 12,000 cars, and that a cruise tax would encourage companies to use less polluting vessels. He said he was looking forward to it.
“Operators have been allowed to get away with contamination for too long,” Slater added.
Amsterdam City Council has voted to close the cruise terminal to curb pollution and reduce tourist numbers.
Moving the terminal outside of the center looks like the most likely solution. But this vote shows the city’s feelings about these mega-ships.
advertisement
Last year, local political leader Ilana Rudelkerk compared cruise passengers landing in the city to a “swarm of locusts.”
Amsterdam introduced a tax on cruise ship passengers in 2019, causing some companies to change or cancel ports of call in the city. More than 100 ships enter the Dutch capital each year, making it emblematic of the local overtourism problem.
Do cruise ships bring in money where they dock?
One of the biggest arguments for those who support keeping cruise ships is their contribution to local economies.
But do passengers aboard these giant ships actually spend their money in the towns where they dock?
Several studies have shown that passengers disembarking ships don’t contribute as much to the local economy as you might think. With food, drinks and souvenirs all on board, your money stays at sea.
advertisement
It’s no surprise then that the world’s largest cruise ship, Wonder of the Seas, is home to an incredible 20 restaurants, a 1,400-seat theater, and shops selling everything from luxury watches to high-end fashion. . Depending on which package you choose, food and drinks are often included, and your shopping is tax and duty free.
An even larger ship, the 365 meter long Icon of the Seas, was launched earlier this year.
A study in Bergen, Norway, a popular destination for fjord tours, found that up to 40 per cent of people never left the boat. For those who did land, the average spend was less than 23 euros.
Further research conducted in Norwegian cities in 2013 found that length of stay is probably one of the biggest factors in how much passengers spend.
The average port stay is approximately 8 hours, but varies greatly depending on the ship’s itinerary. In some cases, like Barcelona, the stop time can be as short as 4 hours.
advertisement
And even as passengers have more opportunities to splurge on cash, spending remains low.
The cruise industry claims passengers’ average contribution to the local economy is much higher than Bergen’s estimate of around $100 (91 euros) per day.
One way to bridge this gap would be to increase passenger taxes levied at ports, which currently tend to range from about 4 euros to 14 euros per person.
The cruise industry says it is working to improve both its environmental and social impact.
According to CLIA, cruise lines are among the first companies in the maritime sector to commit to reducing carbon emissions by 40 percent by 2030. Some have signed a pledge to reach net zero by 2050.
advertisement
Electrifying ports so ships can shut down their engines and limit toxic emissions could also help. This is part of Barcelona’s plan to move cruise ships out of the city by 2026 by allowing ships to dock at Adsat Pier.
But it remains to be seen whether these goals will be enough to appease the port city’s fed up locals.
